As part of your referee report, you should cover the following topics:
What is the research question that the author(s) try to address and why is this issue interesting? (10 points)
How do they answer this question? Specify the methodology and data used and why these are (or are not) adequate choices. Your answer should identify the source of variation in the data and whether or not the methodology is likely to produce causal estimates. (20 points)
Identify and discuss the main results of paper. (10 points)
Find two weak points in the analysis and explain why you are not convinced. Your arguments should have solid economic or econometric foundation. (30 points)
Describe in detail a way to improve the analysis. Your answer should include a discussion of why your suggestion will improve the analysis. (30 points)
