Book Review 4-Highly Competent 3-Competent 2-Minimally Competent 1-Not Competent
Thesis Clearly identifies and critically evaluates the author’s central argument, purpose, and approach to the subject Identifies but not does not critically evaluate the author’s central argument, purpose, and approach to the subject Identified a few main ideas but not the thesis Is unaware of the author’s thesis or the purpose of the book. The review is descriptive but not analytical
Organization The review is exceptionally well organized with an introduction, body, and conclusion and follows the thesis throughout The review is reasonably well organized
The view has a semblance of structure but its coherence is minimized by poor organization The review is disorganized and incoherent
Development A general analysis of the salient features of the book, as opposed to a general summary, and identifies the development of the author’s thesis throughout the book Demonstrates knowledge of the topic and provides supporting evidence and adequate detail Minimal analysis, is repetitious, or and lacks development of salient features of the book being reviewed No analysis, but merely a description of summary of the book’s content
Style Sophisticated sentence structure and paragraph development Effective Use of Language Simplistic sentence structure and imprecise use of language Incorrect sentence structure and use of slang, jargon, or inappropriate language
Mechanics The mechanics of the paper are correct. It is well written with no grammar or punctuation errors, and little or no use of the passive voice Few errors Errors are present that interfere with the presentation of ideas and arguments Excessive errors in grammar and punctuation.
Silbey, David. The Boxer Rebellion and the Great Game in China. New York: Hill and Wang, 2006.
Identify and evaluate the author’s central argument, purpose and approach to the subject. Identify and evaluate the author’s thesis. Be sure to analyze the salient features of the book as opposed to providing a general summary of the book. 3-4 pages. Double-spaced. 1” Margins. Due: 30 April 2014.
