write an argument essay in which you analyze the writer’s argument and you evaluate its effectiveness.
Choose ONE of the articles:
Karen Nachay, “In Search of Sustainability”
John A. Vucetich and Michael P. Nelson, “Sustainability: Virtuous or Vulgar?”, BioScience; Jul/Aug2010, Vol. 60 Issue 7, p539-54
Argument Analysis/Evaluation: An argument analysis examines the components and elements of an argument (as discussed in the related reading assignments in the text) and reaches a conclusion about the extent to which the argument is effective or ineffective. It is NOT a discussion of whether or not you agree with the argument and the writer’s claim.
Your Title: Your essay should have its own title. The title is the first point of contact with the reader. In order for your title to be effective, it should be at least one of the following: original, informative, engaging, or indicative of your attitude towards the subject.
Your Introduction: Remember that your introduction should appeal to your readers’ reason, emotions, and/or sense of ethics (in other words, get their interest). It should additionally identify your topic and end with a clear statement of your claim.
Your Claim/Thesis: Will consist of your evaluation of the degree to which the writer’s argument is convincing
Your Purpose: Your purpose is to accurately interpret and report the point of view presented in the source; to present clearly your evaluation, and to develop a sound argument that supports your position.
Your Audience: A university group whose members are unfamiliar with the original essay
